Rationale and background
Mistra Environmental Communication has the ambition to influence how environmental communication (EC) is practiced in Sweden and beyond. EC practice is however very diverse, ranging from people who engage with EC as a tool for change to those who appreciate its role in meaning-making; from those who think of it as fact-based to those who see it as thoroughly power-laden; or from those who engage in community organising or facilitation to those who create communication campaigns for mass audiences. This diversity can make it difficult to know what the people we engage with think about EC, or whose professional practices we aim to shape. A deep understanding of this ‘target group’ of Mistra Environmental Communication is thus paramount for the success of the programme.
Drawing on 21 interviews with practitioners, several workshops and desk research, the project mapped the diversity and complexity of environmental communication practice in Sweden. It identified different logics that connect “what communication problems practitioners identify” with “what communication is supposed to do”. When not regularly reflected upon, these connections can become self-evident: they turn into professional cultures, wherein practitioners share professional assumptions about how the world works and how they can contribute to changing it through communication, without considering alternative approaches to change or communication.
Main findings
The project explored what communication is assumed to do in practice, different ideals shaping communication, and reflected with practitioners to what extent and when ideals and practices aligned. The study identified four prominent ways in which communication is understood. (These are neither mutually exclusive nor exhaustive.) For EC professionals, communication is variously supposed to:
- influence ideas and behaviours, for example through communication campaigns, outreach, public relations
» communication can change people - manage future communication through controlling access and anticipating responses as conditions are created for making communication (im)possible in the future, for example through agenda-setting, curation or moderation
» communication manages if and how people can participate in future communication - engage stakeholders in collaboration and decision-making, for example through networking, stakeholder co-creation, workshop design and facilitation techniques
» communication involves relevant people or makes them feel involved, in the best case improving decisions - help relationships unfold through open-ended and undirected communication, for example through active listening, openness and curiosity
» communication can create change through new ideas, insights and relationships when people meet
While some practitioners feel comfortable and confident with their own understanding and that of their employer, there are also tensions: often practitioners believe that their employers think of communication as much more focused on influence and control, whereas practitioners’ communication ideals mean they would like to work with more interactional, collaborative, or emergent ways of understanding communication. Others experienced that their employers were not thoroughly committed to environmental causes. More generally, any of these understandings can be problematic if used as a default response to environmental communication problems.
Recommendations
Based on the project’s findings and the experiences of the interviewees, we offer some recommendations for practitioners and researchers on the way to reframing how EC is practiced.
For practitioners
- When dissatisfied with their employer’s engagement with environmental, communication, or environmental communication concerns, practitioners can try to push their employer or their colleagues or try to establish new ways of thinking in their workplace.
- Practitioners can carry out their tasks differently, making environmental concerns visible in the subtext or try out collaborative and emergent ways of fulfilling their communication tasks.
- To reduce the risk of simplification or habitual responses to ever new EC problems, practitioners should look across different ways of doing communication, build networks, and seek to support each other in challenge assumptions about the connection between communication and change.
For researchers
- The framing of professional problems often leads to specific understandings of communication. We found questions such as “what is communication supposed to do in your work?” in combination with questions “what do you consider good communication in your role?” to lead to an unearthing of assumptions and rich discussions, which can provide openings for further dialogue in interventions.
- It appears that many workplaces hold individuals back in reframing EC. This suggests that empowerment should go together with higher-level and systematic interventions in workplaces.
- The doing of communication is tied to professional identities. Seriously reframing it requires practitioners to be able to know and feel confident about knowing when they have done well, which appears to be a problem for some practitioners.
Further reading
Rödl, Mutter, Fischer, Calderon, and Hallgren (in press). Chapter 9: The Professional Cultures of Environmental Communication. In: A Critical Introduction To Environmental Communication. Routledge. (Will be published autumn/winter 2026).
Team
This project was conducted by Christoffer Söderlund Kanarp (SLU) and Karen Schellhase (SLU), led by Malte Rödl (SLU). It was supported by Lars Hallgren (SLU) and Peter Berglez (ÖrU).