How Human-Centred Narratives Undermine EU ‘Sustainable’ Agricultural Strategies

The European Union (EU) promotes carbon farming as a key part of the roadmap to climate neutrality. However, a recent study shows that deep down, EU policies are reluctant to embrace the profound transformations required for the climate crisis. By identifying dominant narratives buried within these policies, which at a surface level appear to strive for sustainable transformations, the study reveals that the EU policies reinforce the status quo. 
A hand that holds a lump of soil.
Photo: Sanna Barrineau

Carbon farming is presented in EU communication and policy documents as a strategy focused on managing plants and soil to capture greenhouse gases. It is seen as a viable practice for restoring soil health and mitigating and adapting to climate change.  

The current EU policy narratives identified in the study, conducted by researchers within Mistra Environmental Communication, are centred around humans and propose business-as-usual technological approaches dominated by economic goals. But the researchers argue that it is necessary to stop seeing soil ecosystems just as a resource to be managed. An example is to stop seeing soil as a “vast reservoir of carbon” and instead start recognising them as a source of life that we depend on. 

According to the study, EU’s narrative hinders alternative ways of imagining our relationship to soil and paths to sustainable transformation, making it difficult to envision alternative futures. 

The study gathered views from carbon farming stakeholders in Sweden and compared them with the EU policy documents. This contrast revealed alternative ways to think about sustainability challenges and opportunities in agriculture. Chiefly, EU policy maintains the age-old notion that, through science and technology, humans can overcome social-ecological crises related to climate, soil health and food security. This indicates a denial of the deep transformations needed for agricultural systems to adapt to the crises. 

Stakeholders, on the other hand, welcomed flexibility and experimentation in diverse farming methods. This shows that, for local farmers, action that generates social, economic and environmental value can be just as important as, if not more important than, the absolute certainty provided by scientific rigour. In other words, an excessive reliance on evidence-based decision-making was viewed with caution. 

In conclusion, the study identifies and reveals dominant narratives buried within EU policies, which at a surface level appear to strive for transformations in sustainability but, in reality, reinforce the status quo. Applying a relational futures lens to the analysis allows us to break down these narratives, which in turn invites us to ask more nuanced questions about desired futures and how to move towards them.

Read the full scientific article here.

This text was written by Léon Videla Jeppsson, Intern within Focus area 5 – Transformation.

Popular science summary of Barrineau, S., Do, T., & Powell, N. (2025). Creating alternative future trajectories for carbon farming through a relational lens: Pathways towards transformative social-ecological change in the European Union. Ecosystems and People, 21(1), 2461535. https://doi.org/10.1080/26395916.2025.2461535 

Share this post
Facebook
LinkedIn

More updates

Can new ways of meeting boost local food production? 

The Hälsingland province in Sweden has a low level of food self-sufficiency, particularly when it comes to fruit and vegetables. To strengthen local food production, local stakeholders from different parts of the food supply chain have come together in a seminar series. The meetings have led to new public procurement agreements as well as unexpected collaborations. 
En grupp personer sitter och diskuterar.

Environmental Communication Day 2026: “It provided a meta-perspective”

In October, the annual Environmental Communication Day opened its doors in Lund, in southern Sweden. The event attracted a large local turnout and it was a fantastic day filled with conversations, discussions, and reflection. “For me, the day was valuable in helping me put into words many of the challenges I face,” said one participant.

Naturlyftet Webinar #3: The Psychology of Encounters with Wild Animals

A webinar on how encounters with wild animals – or the anticipation of such encounters – influence our experience of nature and our relationship with it. The webinar is held in Swedish.

Naturlyftet – Inspirational meeting in Bergslagen for nature guides

Experiences, dialogue and the sharing of insights on communicating biodiversity measures for nature guides and others!

Students arrange a dialogue forum for democracy

In a student led initiative for democracy, Uppsala University, Mistra Environmental Communication and the Environmental Communication and Management programme at SLU invited five local youth political organizations to a dialogue forum to answer student’s burning questions for the upcoming September elections. Present at the dialogue forum were Ung Vänster (UV), Centerpartiets ungdomsförbund (CUF), Moderata ungdomsförbundet (MUF), Grön Ungdom (GU) and Liberala Ungdomsförbundet (LUF). The parties discussed public transport prices, the gap between recent graduates and the job market, the new law for international students limiting the allowed work time outside of university to 15 hours/week for students with residence permits, as well as local food production and food security.
Portrait photo of a smiling Sara.

Sara found a new direction in academia – now her research lives in the forest

Growing up in Storuman, a small town in the north of Sweden, a path to academia was far from a given. Today, Sara Holmgren’s research takes her from Kenya’s bustling cities to the forests of Hälsingland within the space of just a few weeks. Through her co-creative research, she challenges established ways of thinking and works to create change in practice.