Gone with the wind

Gone with the wind: Improving dialogue in relation to decisions on wind power establishments

Wind power is an important energy source for sustainability transformations. Yet it is heavily contested, and its expansion is stagnating. This project explored the potential for constructive communication processes for wind power in sustainability processes.
Contact person

Martin Westin

Martin works in the intersection between governance theory and practice. His research focuses on collaborative governance and participatory planning.

An important part of the transition to sustainability is developing a fossil-free energy system. Wind power, together with other forms of energy, can contribute to this development. However, wind power projects are controversial, and the pace of expansion is being slowed by public opposition. This opposition stems from the perception that wind power negatively impacts the landscape and wildlife, and from the view that the political processes leading up to decisions on wind power projects lack legitimacy.

Communication about wind power takes shape through interactions between stakeholders at the local, national, and international levels. Advocacy coalitions, on various sides of the political spectrum, communicate about wind power with the aim of mobilizing support for their political agendas. Such mobilization efforts take the form of online communication that can be highly biased, confrontational, and even misleading. In the current highly conflictual political context, communication designed to evoke strong negative emotions—such as fear, anger, and sadness—plays a central role. Such destructive communication risks confusing and hindering, rather than enabling, citizens and decision-makers to form well-informed opinions about the path forward in the energy transition. This project was intended to contribute to a shift toward more constructive communication about the role of wind power in the sustainability transition.

The project aimed to improve dialogue regarding wind power establishments. The project work included surveys of experiences with conflict-ridden communication about wind power expansion and analyses of previous attempts to improve dialogue between opposing parties.

Based on these experiences, the communication tool “Dialogkartläggaren” was developed. This tool can be used to inventory dialogue activities and identify areas where dialogue can be strengthened. The project also identified lessons relevant to ongoing policy efforts to improve the permitting process for wind power development.

 

The project has been invited to the podcast ‘The Democracy Journey’ (Demokratiresan) listen here: https://demokratiresan.libsyn.com/175-vindkraftsetablering-ut-ett-lokaldemokratiskt-perspektiv

Essay in Svenska dagbladet: https://www.svd.se/a/BxVrRe/darfor-har-vindkraften-hamnat-i-motvind

 

Team

Martin Westin, SLU and Alexander Hellquist, Uppsala University

The project was conducted in collaboration with the following organizations from the public sector, the business community, and civil society: the Swedish Energy Agency, the Dalarna County Administrative Board, Hela Sverige ska leva, BirdLife Sweden, the Swedish Wind Energy Association, the Municipality of Strömsund, the Municipality of Alvesta, Eolus, and the Nedre Dalälven Biosphere Reserve.

Publications